Food & Drink

Pizza Toppings — The Great Debate

Name: Pizza Toppings — The Great Debate
Creator: Community curated
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Pepperoni, mushroom, pineapple, anchovies — the toppings that define pizza loyalties and destroy friendships.

Rank these by vote →

15rows

5columns

31views

0downloads

Source:Community curated

Updated:3/6/2026

#pizza #toppings #food #italian #debate

15/15

Topping↕	Category↕	Popularity↕	Best Paired With↕	The Hot Take↕
Pepperoni	Meat	#1 in USA	Mozzarella, jalapeños	The default for a reason — crispy edges, grease pools, a simple pleasure that needs no defense
Margherita (fresh mozzarella + basil)	Classic	Universal	San Marzano tomatoes, olive oil	Italian purists say this IS pizza — everything else is an American experiment gone wrong
Mushrooms	Vegetable	Top 5 globally	Truffle oil, garlic, sausage	Earthy umami bomb when done right, rubbery disappointment when done wrong — quality matters
Pineapple (Hawaiian)	Fruit	Divisive	Ham, jalapeños, bacon	The internet's most controversial food choice — sweet + salty works, fight me
Sausage (Italian)	Meat	Top 3 USA	Peppers, onions	Fennel-spiced perfection, hearty and satisfying, the topping that makes a pizza a meal
Black Olives	Vegetable	Moderate	Feta, sun-dried tomatoes	You either pick them off or add extra — no middle ground, Mediterranean essential
Bacon	Meat	High	Ranch drizzle, jalapeños, chicken	Bacon makes everything better, pizza included — crispy strips > crumbled bits, always
Jalapeños	Pepper	Growing fast	Pepperoni, pineapple, bacon	Pickled or fresh? Both. Heat lovers' essential, pairs with everything, the gateway spicy topping
Anchovies	Fish	Niche (but devoted)	Capers, olives, garlic	Hated by most, worshipped by the cultured — salty umami depth that transforms a pizza, acquired taste
BBQ Chicken	Specialty	High (USA)	Red onion, cilantro, gouda	California Pizza Kitchen made it mainstream, BBQ sauce base is controversial, 'is this even pizza?'
Prosciutto	Cured Meat	Moderate-High	Arugula, fig, burrata	Added AFTER baking so it stays silky, the bougie topping that's worth every penny
Buffalo Mozzarella	Cheese	High (Italy)	Cherry tomatoes, basil	Fresh, creamy, milky — makes regular mozzarella feel like plastic, the topping that IS the pizza
Artichoke Hearts	Vegetable	Moderate	Spinach, garlic, ricotta	Underrated Mediterranean gem, tangy and tender, elevates any white pizza
Truffle Oil	Condiment	Trendy	Mushrooms, fontina, egg	A tiny drizzle = luxury, too much = you ruined it, the line between elevated and pretentious is one drop
Nduja	Meat	Rising fast	Burrata, honey drizzle	Spicy spreadable salami from Calabria, melts into the cheese, the topping pizza nerds gatekeep